left arrow BackNext right arrow
< BACK TO Fresh Intelligence

The Journalist And The Purgerer

janetmalcolm_fresh.jpg
CHARMED, I'M SO SURE Malcolm
This morning, the Gossip Girl franchise scored the kind of fan Dan Humphries loves and Blair Waldorf doesn't give a shit about: ultra highbrow, literary luminary Janet Malcolm, who loves her some Gossip Girl books like Chuck Bass loves hos.

In Malcolm's review of the series (in this week's New Yorker—yes, the New Yorker), no esteemed writer is too esteemed to be above a comparison with Cecily von Ziegesar, the author of the GG franchise, who, if you didn't know, scribbles like some combination of Nabokov, Thackery, Waugh, and Tolstoy. Says Malcolm (apparently one of the staffers over whom editor David Remnick can exercise no control; see also John McPhee talking about his grandchildren): "The way von Ziegesar implicates us in her empathic examination of youth's callousness is the Waughish achievement of these strange, complicated books." And, "Nate is a kind of Vronsky manqué, with a grande-dame mother, like Vronsky's, and a Navy-captain father who is 'a master sailor and extremely handsome, but a little lacking in the hugs department. (Too bad Tolstoy didn't think of a father like that for V.)" Oh, snap Tolstoy, you've been served.

But the real reason Malcolm, who knows Serena is a bore and loves Blair so much she "would like to go on telling Blair stories until they are gone," loves the books so much? "After reading the Gossip Girl books, you will never walk into a department store again without feeling a little surge of pride as you recognize Christian Louboutin and John Fluevog and Michael Kors—who are to their world what Marcel Proust and Henry James and Theodore Dreiser are to the bookish audience for whom von Ziegesar writes in the guise of writing for the pre-S.A.T. young." Gossip Girl—teaching old ladies to ID Christian Louboutin!

Comments

Be the first to respond. Post your comment below.

Advertisement


Post a comment

Your comment will not be visible for about a minute. If you don't see your comment when the page reloads, do not post it again. Reload the page in a minute, and you'll see it.

 


The Chris Matthews Race and Gender Reel

Britney Seeks Divine Wisdom from Mel

'Worst Person on the Internet' Finally Indicted

Headline of the Day

Pharmaceutical Slogans For Politicians

Sources: WaPo Executive Editor Leonard Downie Out in '09

Anthony Pellicano Goes Down

Jose Canseco Wants to Whoop You

British Teens Imperil the Future of the Nation by Climbing Things, Jumping Off Them

California Supreme Court Overturns Ban On Gay Marriage


EXECUTIVE EDITOR:


EDITED BY:
, with

CONTRIBUTORS:
, , and others


Email us at:
tips@radaronline.com
or IM: TipRadar







Full Court Press
Charles Kaiser on Torture Team: Rumsfeld's Memo and the Betrayal of American Values

Generation Slap
They're naive, self-important, and perpetually plugged in. This is a call to arms against Millennials

MURDER! MUTILATION! CANNIBALISM!
One man's tour through the world of death metal

Homosexual Agenda
Gayest Person Ever? Author Joel Derfner wants the title

Full Court Press
Frank Rich leads this week's list of Winners and Sinners





House Speaker Nancy Pelosi Brings the Pain
It's getting hot in here

Your '80s Heroes Are Now Losers
Just as messed up as we hoped

A post-Obama world is a good world
Yes, he did

Bush the Third
You've been warned

A younger Bill O'Reilly gets angry
But did he ever have it?